They'll be better off if they permanently switch him to an everyday hitter whether DH or put him in the OF. The Yankees certainly knew Babe Ruth was much more valuable as a hitter and they got plenty of value out of him. Realistically for the next five years the Dodgers need Ohtani to average around .300, 40 HR, and 110 RBI and hope of course that he exceeds those numbers. Which is what the Yankees would like to get out of Judge as well.

The Braves probably got the best deal and bargain for signing Matt Olson to less than 300 million. He had the best power numbers out of everyone in 2023.